We Should Talk Review - A Modern Take on Romance Sims - Comic Years
Comic Years Logo

We Should Talk Review – A Modern Take on Romance Sims

author img
BY July 14, 2020

Romance sims are either fairly normal or totally perverse. A lot of the visual novels I play tend to leave me a little letdown. Therefore, I’m happy to see something like We Should Talk getting the attention it deserves. A lot of buzz around this game occurred weeks before its release and now we’re finally about to see it hit consoles and PC this Thursday, July 16. If you’re not sure what this game is about, or whether it’s for you, then hopefully this We Should Talk review helps!

We Should Talk – A New Take on Dating Sims

we should talk review Image Credit: Whitethorn Games

This is a spoiler-free review of We Should Talk

We Should Talk aims to be inclusive and representative. Much like other games released in 2020 such as Coffee Talk, we’re seeing more LGBTQ+ stories take place in the gaming medium. It’s crucial to tell these stories but to also portray them as normal and routine rather than something to catch the eye. We Should Talk does this masterfully. You play the game as someone with a girlfriend named Sam, who doesn’t share your interest in going out to the bar. As it turns out, you go out a lot. Like, multiple times a week. She’s pretty cool about it, but she’s also concerned that you might be meeting strangers. As it turns out, you’re not meeting strangers, but you do have a few familiar faces in the bar with you the night the game takes place.

Image Credit: Whitethorn Games

As you play, you meet three characters. Steph, the bartender, who notices Sam isn’t with you and seems a bit flirtatious. Secondly, Dante is an ex of yours, and he indicates early on that your relationships fell apart because you two were in different places. Shocker: he thinks you’d work out much better now, and possibly tonight. Lastly, Jimmy is a dating app fling you may or may not have planned on meeting up with tonight. As you progress through the game, you get a chance to talk to all three of them, as well as text Sam who waits for you back at home. It’s up to you to figure out who you want to build your relationship around for the night.

We Should Talk Review Score

Image Credit: Whitethorn Games

I review games on a scale of 1-10; We Should Talk is a solid 7. While the game is incredibly short, you can revisit it multiple times to get a feel for each storyline. I ran things the first time around with Sam, the girlfriend at home, in mind at the forefront. Then, I revisited other options. Something that We should talk Team nails is the ability to explore each person in a very unique way. You get four individuals to pursue, but also plenty of dialogue options that can sway how time with them goes. This game doesn’t look particularly great, but I failed to notice the visuals once the game got going.

we should talk review Image Credit: Whitethorn Games

All things considered, the game does a great job of offering a diverse and inclusive take on dating sims. There’s nothing there that feels gratuitously sexual or perverse, but there is intimacy with each character should you choose to pursue it. If you like dating sims, then I think this is a good pick-up.

we should talk review Image Credit: Whitethorn Games

We Should Talk releases Thursday, July 16 for Switch, Xbox One, PS4, and Steam. A digital review code was provided by the publisher for the purposes of this review.

Featured Image Credit: Whitethorn Games


Taylor loves to play video games in his spare time. He has two degrees in Political Communication and wrote his thesis on Marxism and the exploitation of college athletes. In his spare time, he loves spending time with his wife and two Toy Australian Shepherds. He’s always got headphones in, and he’s a diehard Cubs fan.

Game ReviewsGamingromance sims

Leave a comment


Xbox Series S Reveal – Price, Release Date, and Everything We Know

We’re months away from the holiday season. Scary right? Well, we have a major console release from two of the three biggest names in gaming too. There are so many questions about these consoles and […]

BY Taylor Bauer September 8, 2020
Book Review: The Mythology And Magic Of The Poet King Will Transport You To A New World

Ilana C. Myer wrote the first book of The Harp and Ring sequence to function as a standalone novel. Last Song Before Night came out in 2015 to much critical acclaim. A trip to Spain inspired a follow-up […]

BY Emily O'Donnell April 12, 2020
DC ComicsReviewsTV Shows
Legends Of Tomorrow Season 5 Finale Is a Meditation On Mistakes And The Allure Of The Thong Song

To my surprise, it appears that Legends of Tomorrow was able to complete their intended season 5 finale despite the COVID-19 shutdown. Fifteen episodes seems like a strange number for a season of television, but […]

BY Joshua M. Patton June 3, 2020

Rail Ad Editorial Content

Rail Ad