MSNBC’s Rachel Maddow Cast in Batwoman: They’re Just Trolling the Haters Now

author img
BY October 5, 2019

After the first Batwoman trailer faced backlash, many folks wondered if Batwoman can survive the fan-hate it received. At the core of the anger towards the show were bad-faith accusations of misandry, because star Ruby Rose’s Kate Kane said the batsuit would be perfect “when it fits a woman.” Now, any new project related to the bat-family meets some sort of fan resistance, just ask new Batman Robert Pattinson. Yet, in their latest casting move, the producers seem to be trolling their trolls. Liberal opinion journalist on MSNBC Rachel Maddow is cast in Batwoman as a character from the Batman comics. This is not the first time Maddow has acted in a scripted series, but it will be the first time she plays anyone other than herself.

Why Cast Rachel Maddow at All?

Rachel Maddow Cast in Batwoman Rachel Maddow Talk Image by JD Lascia via Flickr

Rachel Maddow is a longtime broadcaster and political journalist who gained national recognition with her radio show on the now-defunct Air America network. She began to appear on MSNBC during the George W. Bush years as a frequent guest on Keith Olbermann’s now-defunct MSNBC flagship show Countdown. Eventually, she won her own series on the network where she reports on stories that she cares about. Unlike some journalists, Maddow does not remain objective in all things. She has a clear political bent (which is not, in and of itself a bad thing). She’s gained a reputation for slow-burn reporting, often taking a full 15-minutes or more to walk through stories. She’s also a passionate supporter of military veterans, featuring many on her program to highlight veteran issues. She also wrote a book called Drift about the struggles soldiers face returning home from war.

Kate Kane is also a veteran, whose skills learned in the military are the basis for her skills as Batwoman. Maddow has an affection for the character, perhaps for that reason and because of LGBT+ representation in comic books. She also wrote the forward for a Batwoman trade hardcover, celebrating what an out lesbian superhero would have meant to Maddow growing up. Maddow previous appeared in a number of scripted, fictional series, but always as herself. This will be the first time she’ll portray a character. She doesn’t appear to be slated to appear in person (yet), but will simply do voiceover work as Vesper Fairchild. The radio commentator character will have Strong Opinions™ about a female vigilante at work in Gotham.

As showrunner Caroline Dries said about the decision to cast Rachel Maddow in Batwoman to The Hollywood Reporter:

“We consider Vesper Fairchild to be the sardonic Voice of Gotham…. In addition to Rachel’s interest in Batwoman, we thought she’d be the perfect casting choice because her own hard-hitting journalism wildly contrasts Vesper’s penchant for snark, gossip and criticism of female superheroes.”

Who is Vesper Fairchild and What Does She Have to Do With the Bat-Family?

Rachel Maddow Cast in Batwoman Who Is Vesper Fairchild Image via DC

Vesper Fairchild is one of the many women who’ve had relationships in the comics with Bruce Wayne. In fact, before the last continuity reboot, Fairchild ended up murdered in Wayne Manor, and Bruce Wayne was the prime suspect. In the Arrowverse, Fairchild has been mentioned before. During the Elseworlds crossover event last year, Fairchild supposedly had an intimate relationship with Oliver Queen. Since this version of Fairchild has a penchant for billionaire playboys (who double as vigilantes), she may also have been involved with Bruce Wayne. In Batwoman, Kane is Wayne’s cousin and he’s been missing for some time. (This is, of course, because the real-world rights to the character don’t allow Batman to appear in the show at all.)

It seems that for the first season, at least, Fairchild will merely be a voice in a speaker, criticizing Kane’s burgeoning vigilante efforts. However, it seems unlikely that Maddow will never appear on-screen as the character. Of course, logistics would be an issue. Batwoman films in Vancouver, while Maddow’s nightly show films in New York. Still, they take time off and guest hosts fill in periodically. So, Maddow could make a trip up to the set. It’s unclear if Fairchild will have a similar affection for Ruby Rose’s Kate Kane. The Arrowverse already features two bisexual heroes, Caity Lotz’s Sarah Lance (AKA the White Canary) and Matt Ryan’s John Constantine.

While this seems like a very small role, that they cast Rachel Maddow in Batwoman at all seems to be a deliberate taunt to the show’s haters. Those who have a problem with Batwoman also likely have a problem with Maddow.

What do you think of the decision to cast Rachel Maddow in Batwoman? Tell us in the comments below!

Featured image via screengrab

TV Shows

Joshua M. Patton is a father, veteran, and writer living in Pittsburgh, PA. The first books he read on his own were comics, and he's loved the medium ever since. He is the greatest star-pilot in the galaxy, a cunning warrior, and a good friend. His book "What I Learned: Stories, Essays, and More" is available in print from Amazon and from all electronic booksellers.

Leave a comment


TV Shows
Gotham Series Finale Is a Fitting End to an Insane Television Show

After five crazy season, the Batman prequel on Fox came to an end. Let’s dive into the Gotham series finale in this retrospective.

BY Joshua M. Patton April 28, 2019
TV Shows
Amazon Posts, Then Deletes Teaser Trailer for The Boys Season 2

In late July of this year, Amazon Prime Video had a hit on their hands with the first season of a superhero series based on characters created by Garth Ennis. Part of the wave of deconstructionist takes on superheroes, The Boys was a hit, so much so that Amazon renewed the series for season 2 […]

BY Joshua M. Patton December 5, 2019
TV Shows
Rick and Morty’s Jessica Gao to Write She-Hulk TV Series

Jessica Gao, known for her work on shows like Silicon Valley and Rick and Morty, will head the writers’ room for the She-Hulk TV series coming to Disney+. In case you’re not familiar with Gao or with She-Hulk, here’s why it’s easy being green. Jessica Gao Is an Experienced TV Writer Gao got her start […]

BY Salomé Gonstad November 11, 2019
Revenge of the Sith Retro Review – The Game

As a child of the mid 90s, I grew up heavily impacted by the Star Wars prequels. I remember attending a birthday party to see The Phantom Menace, having no knowledge there were others released decades ago. I became obsessed, and after seeing The Clone Wars, I was all aboard the hype train for Revenge […]

BY Taylor Bauer February 18, 2020
Best Rebuilds for NBA 2K20 – MyLeague Tips

I’m a huge fan of NBA 2K20, but most of my time is spent in one area of the game. While some work to become dribble gods on MyPark, I stick to MyLeague. Solely, for the the experience of managing a team. Working to rebuild teams on MyLeague is the reason I average over 200 […]

BY Taylor Bauer February 17, 2020
E3 Veteran Geoff Keighley Skipping Conference in 2020

I think one thing I love about video game journalism is getting to talk games. On the best day, covering gaming news involves great reveals, exciting titles, and hopes for my favorite series. On the worst day, I can usually say the downers about gaming journalism involve the industry. Sometimes, profits and sponsors get in […]

BY Taylor Bauer February 17, 2020
Marvel’s Avengers Pre-Order Deals: Where to Get The Best Bonus

Pre-ordering games used to be a way to make sure you had a highly anticipated title as soon as possible. Now, pre-orders are a sort of incentive for extra content and goodies. A fun bonus is usually enough to get me to pre-order a game, and an upcoming Marvel video game fits that bill for […]

BY Taylor Bauer February 14, 2020


Disney+ Reveals First Clip of Season 7 of Star Wars: The Clone Wars by Highlighting the Bad Batch

Star Wars fans may eagerly await the next story in the films or season 2 of The Mandalorian. However, the most anticipated new thing is something, well, old. After debuting the release date for Season 7 of Star Wars: The Clone Wars, Disney+ released the first preview clip highlighting the Bad Batch. The title of […]

BY Joshua M. Patton February 19, 2020
Ben Affleck Opens Up About Why He Stopped Being The Batman In New Interview

The Batman is dead, long live the Batman! This is how it is for fans of the caped crusader. Sure, Bruce Wayne may be ageless and eternal in the pages of DC Comics for 80 years, but mere mortals age. Michael Keaton is more like Bruce Wayne in the Batman Beyond series than the character […]

BY Joshua M. Patton February 19, 2020
Alas, Green Arrow and the Canaries Has Not Yet Been Picked Up By the CW, Producer Confirms

For fans of the Arrowverse, specifically those who are sad about the Arrow series finale, Twitter got exciting in the wee hours of the morning. A writer for another site, who did successfully predict Titans being renewed for season 3, dropped what seemed like a seedling of hope. He said that Green Arrow and the […]

BY Joshua M. Patton February 19, 2020
Set Video of Woody Harrelson as Cletus Kasady Shows Him Doing…Something Bad?

Venom fans got their first, long-awaited look at the man who would be Carnage in action today. A set video showing Woody Harrelson as Cletus Kasady hit the internet. Much of the focus on Venom 2 has been on the reports that Tom Holland’s Spider-Man might make an appearance. Since Sony and Disney reached a […]

BY Joshua M. Patton February 18, 2020