Brightburn Superman is Evil, but Not Evil Enough

author img
BY September 29, 2019

Brightburn Superman has an interesting premise—what if Superman, as a boy, turned evil. Sound terrifying, right? A kid with super strength, laser eyes, freezing breath, and flight who is a sociopathic murderer? Yeah, that town is going to be destroyed in a matter of…

…never?

While Brightburn definitely has its moments, it never comes close to living up to the evil Superman idea. We see the boy, Brandon Breyer, commit some pretty gruesome and crazy murders, but for a story like this, we don’t see enough. Maybe they are saving it for a sequel, but that’s always risky (Alita: Battle Angel had a similar problem). We’re teased with awesomeness but that’s it. We don’t get the full scale of what he’s capable of, just hints. And, since we know what Superman is capable of, whether as a teen in Smallville or as an adult in Man of Steel, not seeing Brandon go big is disappointing.

The Good Stuff – Brightburn Superman

But, while the writing may be off, the Brightburn does deliver in many areas, and when it keeps the Superman trope in mind, it really pays off. It would be easy to see the movie as a critique of superhero films, but I don’t think that’s what we’re seeing. Instead, Brightburn is kind of a bizarre love letter to Superman and superheroes (film or comics). We get the Smallville like setting, the alien spaceship locked in a barn, the loving parents who just wanted a child, etc. However, the design crew took some of the best elements of Man of Steel to twist for the movie. If it were a criticism, they would have taken the worst (like when Ozymandias in the Watchmen movies has nipples on his rubber suit, mocking the design choices Batman & Robin). For instance, here is Brandon’s mask in Brightburn:

general zod superman
Pa! I look just like you! (Columbia Pictures)

And here is General Zod and his minions in Man of Steel:

 

Brightburn Superman
No, son. You are a terrible disappointment. (Warner Bros.)

Brightburn Embraces Evil

In fact, though Brightburn sells itself as a “what if Superman were evil” story, it’s really a “what if Zod fell to Earth instead?” That love letter? Oh, it’s for the supervillains who have kind of been forgotten for the last few years. We’ve had Thanos, Loki, Vulture, Joker (Heath Ledger…and maybe Joaquin Phoenix if we’re lucky). But most villains have been on the bland side even when the movies are great (Hello Ronan the Accuser). And the spaceship that Brandon arrives in is deliciously evil-looking:

Brightburn spaceship
This should have been the Breyers’ first sign of trouble. (Columbia Pictures)

And the evil-meta doesn’t stop there. There’s a lot of nuggets, but the best one in Brightburn is having “Superman” pulls a “women in refrigerators” murder by literally killing a woman in a refrigerator.

brightburn
Save me, Gail Simone! (Columbia Pictures)

Brightburn Superman Evil Looks Good

The movie also does well with cinematography. Some of Brightburn’s renditions of Superman scenes (from any movie) are better than the actual Superman scenes. When he flies for the first time, you want to cheer for this sadistic 12-year-old. The quintessential “Superman flies someone up beyond the clouds” moment has a beautiful quality that almost doesn’t fit in this movie—but it does because of the moment right after.

Also, the few people Brandon does kill, he kills in pretty memorable ways. The movie doesn’t have a lot of gore, but when it does, it’s used really well. I’m not a fan of jump scares or over-the-top gore (it feels boring), but done just enough, it pulls me in. We get to see what Brandon is capable of because of it (even if we never see him reach his potential).

The Kids Are All Right

The acting is a bit problematic too. Usually, in a film like this, it’s the kids who would have trouble selling their roles. But here, it’s the opposite. The big star in Brightburn is, of course, our evil pre-teen Superman played by Jackson A. Dunn. The kid delivers. He plays the normal teenage boy, before discovering his powers, really well. And when he goes evil, his quietness makes it more believable. The other kid is Emmie Hunter, who plays the Caitlyn, a girl that Brandon has a crush on (and then crushes her hand). If you watched this, or plan to, and it felt like they were building Emmie up to be really important, you aren’t wrong. But despite being a really important character for the first two-thirds of the movie, she just kind of disappears—another problem with either the writing, editing, or directing.

Brightburn Superman
Future Peter Parker? (Columbia Pictures)

The Parents? Not So Much…

The adults….meh. Elizabeth Banks is kind of annoying as Brandon’s mom, Tori. She has two notes as Tori: Doting mother or worried doting mother. Even when Brandon starts killing people she loves, Banks acts in a way where it seems that she supports her kid’s murderous behavior. Maybe that would have been an interesting twist, but it’s not. When Brandon mutilates Caitlyn’s hand, she defends him a little too much. I doubt there would be many parents who would argue with the other child’s mother over why her son is innocent, even as she acknowledges the incident. Sure, defensive, but Banks plays it as if it is somehow the other mom’s fault.

Elizabeth Banks Brightburn
One of her two facial expressions in the entire movie. (Columbia Pictures)

Similarly, David Denman has almost no range playing the father, Kyle. Where Banks had two notes, Denman has one: stoic. Kyle actually has a really interesting character arc, but you wouldn’t know it because Denman is so boring, it’s hard to even remember most of his scenes. It’s like he was trying to channel Kevin Costner in Man of Steel but had less emotional depth than the chickens Brandon kills.

Supermeh

Brightburn is a bit of a mixed bag. It’s enjoyable, but it’s not memorable and a great concept, but not a great story. It’s an interesting reversal on the superhero origin, but not strong enough not to rely on the connections. At the end of the day, though, it’s a fun movie, and for some reason, I want to see it again, if only to try catching more references and Easter eggs.

Grade: C

Next time, get a dog!

You know what the real difference is between Brandon Breyer and Clark Kent? Clark had a pet dog. Brandon had no pet at all. See what happens when you don’t give your kid a pet? Brandon could have been like this:

Brightburn Superman
I’m smiling and normal because pets teach us empathy and caring. (Warner Bros.)

But instead, he turns into this:

ZODI
ALL I WANTED WAS A KITTEN! (DC Comics)

Check out more reviews and movie news on our movie page!

Movies

Roman Colombo finished his MFA in 2010 and now teaches writing and graphic novel literature at various Philadelphia colleges. His first novel, Trading Saints for Sinners, was published in 2014. He's currently working on his next novel and hoping to find an agent soon.

Leave a comment

Related

MoviesPop CultureTV Shows
The CBS And Viacom Merger: Is This The Studios’ Solution For The Perceived Netflix Threat?

With CBS and Viacom merging again, will the franchises under the one banner be enough to compete against Netflix?

BY Shah Shahid August 22, 2019
COMICSDCMoviesPop Culture
Black Superman? The Rock Thinks it’s Time, and He’s Right

While promoting Hobbs and Shaw, Dwayne “The Rock” Johnson talked with Variety about the rising diversity in superhero films. While praising Marvel, and then quickly remembering that he is going to be in Black Adam—a DC movie (awkward), he said that he thinks we’ll soon see a black superman (and that you’re looking at him). […]

BY Roman Colombo July 17, 2019
COMICSMarvelMovies
X-Men: Dark Phoenix Review: Good Movie, Imperfect End

The final film in the 20-year X-Men film series debuted. Dive into our X-Men: Dark Phoenix review to see what the film gets right, wrong, and what’s next.

BY Joshua M. Patton June 7, 2019
Fortnite Chapter 2 Trailer Intros New Map

Quite possibly the biggest game around right now, Fortnite is looking to keep players interested and invested with some major changes. If you didn’t catch the Fortnite chapter 2 trailer, here’s everything you need to know about the new map and things Epic Games is introducing. Fortnite Chapter 2 Trailer Shows Off New Digs There […]

BY Taylor Bauer October 15, 2019
Fortnite Season 11 Darkness Sends Fans into Uproar

Ahead of Fortnite’s newest season, which is the game’s 11th if you’re keeping score at home, Epic Games raised the stakes. Rather than hype players up with a crazy loot drop, or new in-game features, the Fortnite map we all know and love disappeared. Literally, as there is currently no map to play Fortnite on. […]

BY Taylor Bauer October 14, 2019
Google Stadia Broadband Caps Cause Major Concern

There are a lot of changes coming to the video game industry. For starters, the major home console makers are setting the stage for a new generation. We’re expected to see the new PS5 and Microsoft’s Xbox Scarlett (name pending) next year for the holidays. Plus, the Switch Lite is now on shelves, providing a […]

BY Taylor Bauer October 14, 2019
Fortnite Profits Drop Steeply – Is the Fad Waning?

Flash back to the 2018 holiday season. Fortnite, a free to play multiplayer titan, seemed unstoppable. Like anything in pop culture, however, nothing lasts at its peak forever. Recent news that Fortnite profits drop steeply when you look at 2019 Q2 trends points to some positives and negatives for Epic Games moving forward. Why did […]

BY Taylor Bauer October 10, 2019

Trending

Kevin Feige Promoted to Chief Creative Officer at Marvel Studios, Overseeing, Well, Everything

That a seismic shake-up was underway at Marvel was apparent. The Sony and Disney standoff over Spider-Man, rumors that Marvel Studios would take over Marvel Television, and an ambitious MCU Phase 4 line-up. However, what that shake-up was remained a mystery until now. Kevin Feige, president of Marvel Studios, was promoted to Chief Creative Officer, […]

BY Joshua M. Patton October 15, 2019
Fortnite Chapter 2 Trailer Intros New Map

Quite possibly the biggest game around right now, Fortnite is looking to keep players interested and invested with some major changes. If you didn’t catch the Fortnite chapter 2 trailer, here’s everything you need to know about the new map and things Epic Games is introducing. Fortnite Chapter 2 Trailer Shows Off New Digs There […]

BY Taylor Bauer October 15, 2019
Doctor Doom #1 Shows He Loves Latveria More than Doom

Doctor Victor Von Doom, the ruler of the fictional country Latveria, might have the biggest ego in comics. It’s a toss-up between him and Lex Luthor, really. And as one of the biggest villains in Marvel Comics, Doom has caused mayhem and death all over the universe. So, how is it possible that he not […]

BY Roman Colombo October 15, 2019
Zoe Kravitz Will Be The Batman’s Catwoman

After a series of screen tests with various actresses, it is now official. Zoe Kravitz will play Catwoman, opposite Robert Pattinson, in Matt Reeves’s The Batman. Here are the details we know so far about her role, including, perhaps, the most surprising part of her casting. What Role Will Catwoman Play in the Upcoming Movie? […]

BY Salomé Gonstad October 15, 2019