Creepshow Holiday Special Is a Yuletide Delight - Comic Years
Comic Years Logo

Creepshow Holiday Special Is a Yuletide Delight

author img
BY December 20, 2020

I have to confess something. I didn’t love the Creepshow Animated Special. Don’t get me wrong–the stories were good, obviously, and the performances were fine. However, I didn’t care for the animation style. So when I heard about the Creepshow Holiday Special, I was a little reserved. Unlike its predecessor, though, it’s live-action, and it is wonderful.

Creepshow Holiday Special: Plot Details (Tender and Mild Spoilers)

creepshow holiday special image via Shudder

Adam Pally, whom you should already know from the great Happy Endings, stars as Robert Weston. Weston, if I may call him that, has a bit of an issue. Due to the uh, goings of his digestive system, he’s realized that he’s ingesting some weird shit. If he had pica or some condition like that, then there would be an easy explanation. However, he not only doesn’t have any known conditions, but he also doesn’t remember eating anything like coins or buttons. Or bones.

So once bodies start turning up, he starts to believe that he might be responsible. In fact, he suspects that he might be a shapeshifter, so he attends a meeting of the local chapter of Shapeshifters Anonymous. The password he tries to use to get into the meeting, by the way, is “Landis“–wink, wink.

The folks at the meeting are a friendly bunch, ready and willing to help Weston crack the mystery. They include Dr. Talbot (Keith Flippen), who shifts into a turtle, and Irena (Anna Camp), who’s a were-cheetah. Her casting almost feels like a fun throwback to Camp’s time on True Blood. From Club Dead, the third book in The Southern Vampire Mysteries, upon which the series was based:

And they might call themselves by that animal: weredog, or werebat, or weretiger. But never just ‘weres’-that term was reserved for the wolves. The true werewolves scorned such variance in form, and they didn’t think much of shifters in general. They, the werewolves, considered themselves the cream of the shape-shifting world.

Ahem. Anyway, once they establish Weston as a true shifter, they let him in on another secret. Ever since Biblical times, shifters have been in an ongoing struggle with Santa Claus, a villain who wishes to eradicate every one of them. I’m sure there’s no way he’ll find them at the Church of St. Argento, though, right?

J.A. Konrath Adaptation a Holiday Joy

creepshow holiday special image via Shudder

Despite my thinking of Charlaine Harris, the special is actually based on a short story by J.A. Konrath. And for the most part, it works. The characters at the shifters’ meeting, which also includes a were-boar (Andy, played by Frank Nicotero), are so secure with who they are that it’s refreshing. No glum, angsty weres here.

And when the inevitable ultraviolence breaks out, that’s fun, too. If I had one quibble with the special, then it would be the characterization of Phyllis (Candy McClellan). There’s a long and inglorious history of comparing Black people, particularly Black women, to animals. That Phyllis isn’t even a real were–she’s just a really enthusiastic furry–doesn’t matter. Too often in the special, Phyllis is the object of derision or pity. (Note: I haven’t read the novella yet, so I don’t know if all this comes from the source.) There’s also an outdated detail regarding an elderly Roma woman. Y’all can come for me all you want, but c’mon. It’s 2020 and we’re still doing this stuff?

At the same time, though, that does add to the retro feel of the Creepshow Holiday Special. So having said that, it’s obviously not perfect. But it might be perfect for you if you can’t stand another schmaltzy holiday movie. (But please stay tuned for the one I’m going to write, where a big city werewolf–in an immaculate camel wool wrap coat–has a meet-cute with a small town…werewolf.)

The Creepshow Holiday Special is available now on Shudder.

And as always, let us know what you think. Comment here or on our social media.

featured image via Shudder

TV Shows

Salomé Gonstad is a freelance writer who grew up in the swampy wilds of south Alabama. When she's not yelling about pop culture on the internet, she's working on a supernatural thriller about her hometown. Also, we're pretty sure she's a werewolf. Email her at


Leave a comment


TV Shows
Patty Jenkins Earns $10 Million Deal With Netflix

It’s only been a few years since Wonder Woman, the 2017 DC film directed by Patty Jenkins earned an expectation-succeeding $821 million at the box office. The film sparked endless conversations about female representation on-screen […]

BY Meghan Hale September 8, 2019
DC ComicsTV Shows
Swamp Thing Season Finale Review: A Slow-Burn Series Extinguished Before Its Time

The Swamp Thing season finale ended the fantastic series, but in a bittersweet way because so many great set-ups will never be paid off.

BY Joshua M. Patton August 3, 2019
TV Shows
Mindhunter Season 2 Review: The Downfall Of Following Reality

Mindhunter first released on Netflix in October of 2017. Fans became immediately intrigued by the true-crime series, created by Joe Penhall, with co-executive producers David Fincher and Charlize Theron. Loosely following John E. Douglas and […]

BY Meghan Hale August 19, 2019

Rail Ad Editorial Content

Rail Ad