Batwoman TV Show Review: Did It Deserve the Backlash?

author img
BY October 7, 2019

When I wrote about the backlash to the Batwoman TV show’s trailers, I admittedly had no skin in the game. This may be received as sacrilege, but I don’t actually watch any of The CW’s superhero block. I also have no feelings about Batwoman, positive or negative. So my approach to the backlash was almost academic. Basically, I was curious what the big deal was. And that’s what drove me to watch the pilot episode–curiosity as to how it all turned out after all that fuss. If you’re curious, too, then here’s a review of the Batwoman TV show that will give you all the answers.

The Basic Details: What’s Up with Batwoman?

CW Batwoman Review Image via CW

In the beginning, there is no Batwoman. There’s just a woman named Kate Kane (Ruby Rose). She lives in a Gotham that hasn’t seen hide nor hair nor bat cowl of the Batman in 3 years. In the interim, her father, Colonel Jacob Kane (Dougray Scott) and his company, Crows Private Security, have taken charge of keeping Gotham safe.

Kicked out of military school (because of her relationship with fellow student Sophie (Meagan Tandy)) and shipped away by her father, she’s been off doing…other stuff (?), I guess. All that’s kinda handwaved away. Mostly she’s trying to avoid her family. When she was a child, she was the only survivor of a car accident that killed her mom and sister. Her dad has since remarried–to Catherine Hamilton-Kane (Elizabeth Anweis)–and I would guess that didn’t help heal the rift between father and daughter.

That rift is only widened by the events of the pilot, by the way. Having not heard from Batman in years, the city prepares to turn off the Bat-Signal (at a weirdly exclusive event). Before they can do that, though, a mysterious woman, Alice (Rachel Karsten), and her goons interrupt the ceremony and kidnap Sophie. Kate can’t handle that, so she goes full-on vigilante. First stop, her cousin Bruce Wayne’s building, because he has all the cool tech. Can’t imagine she’ll find anything else interesting there.

I’ll Quit Stalling and Give You the Batman TV Show Review

CW Batwoman Review Image via screengrab

On the surface, there’s a lot to like about the pilot. Outside of the father-daughter relationship, for example, I liked Kate’s story. Her relationships with other people–stepsister Mary (Nicole Kang) and Lucius Fox’s son Luke (Camrus Johnson), in particular–added levity and real emotion. And speaking of relationships, as the wreck that killed her family informs everything Kate does, it’s handled well. The flashbacks look like hot garbage, but I like the way the story is told.

And I like the story of Alice. After being quite whelmed by Joker last week, it’s refreshing to see someone menace Gotham with a plan. The show comes alive whenever she’s onscreen. That’s a good thing, because the pilot could be dull and draggy in parts. It’s livened up by fight scenes, which are less muddled than DC fights usually are, but then sunk again by bland line readings of corny lines.

Here Comes the Downside of Batwoman

CW Batwoman Review Image via CW

In addition, again, I’m not an expert on CW superhero shows, so I don’t know all of their tropes. But I have seen a few episodes, and it feels like they have a factory that spits out side characters, like the tech wizard and the flighty sister. This could be the result of all of these characters being products of decades-old stories, but I’m just saying that once you notice it, it’s hard not to keep noticing it.

On that note, here’s another thing I noticed. While some of the backlash has been about “SJWs” or arguments that the show is too woke or not woke enough, I don’t care about any of that. While I notice tired cliches, of course, I don’t monitor programs to check if they’re problematic or not. But it’s hard not to notice when the show’s first non-Kate character is an indigenous man, especially when he talks like Tonto. “You find way. Own way. Tomorrow, find faster.” I can’t believe it’s the 90s and TV shows are still pulling this nonsense. Overall, my review of the Batwoman TV show is pretty positive. It wasn’t a stunner from the jump, but there’s room to move and room to improve. And room to never do whatever that scene with the native man was again.

CW will air the Batwoman pilot again Tuesday and Saturday nights, returning with new episodes Sunday at 8 p.m.

Did you watch the Batwoman premiere? Let us know what you thought in the comments or on social mediums.

featured image via The CW

DCTV Shows

Salomé Gonstad is a freelance writer who grew up in the swampy wilds of south Alabama. She now splits her time between the Appalachian wilds (of Alabama) and the considerably more refined streets of New York City. When she's not yelling about pop culture on the internet, she's working on a supernatural thriller about her hometown. Also, we're pretty sure she's a werewolf.

Leave a comment

Related

Pop CultureTV Shows
15th Anniversary of LOST: Remembering the Show That Changed How We Watched TV Forever

On September 22, 2004 a plane fell out of the sky onto a strange island in the South Pacific packed with mysteries, ghosts, and a smoke monster. On the 15th anniversary of LOST, we at Comic Years are looking back at the genre-bending television show that changed the way we watch television. Serialized television was […]

BY Joshua M. Patton September 24, 2019
TV Shows
SDCC Gets First Look At CW’s Nancy Drew Series

Nancy Drew, the gateway drug for people who now have strong opinions about true crime podcasts, will make its debut on The CW this fall. It is not the TV debut for the book series–this isn’t the first time there’s been a Nancy Drew series or even the most recent attempt. The CW clearly thinks […]

BY Salomé Gonstad July 19, 2019
TV Shows
HBO Max Adds Greek Mythology Tale Circe To Line Up

There are lots of things going on in the world of the streaming wars. Sure, there’s some intense stuff like D.C. lobbying, or fighting for the right price bundles. But, at the heart of it all, is looking for the right new content. The newest announcement of original content is HBO Max with an adaptation […]

BY Meghan Hale August 15, 2019
Fortnite Chapter 2 Trailer Intros New Map

Quite possibly the biggest game around right now, Fortnite is looking to keep players interested and invested with some major changes. If you didn’t catch the Fortnite chapter 2 trailer, here’s everything you need to know about the new map and things Epic Games is introducing. Fortnite Chapter 2 Trailer Shows Off New Digs There […]

BY Taylor Bauer October 15, 2019
Fortnite Season 11 Darkness Sends Fans into Uproar

Ahead of Fortnite’s newest season, which is the game’s 11th if you’re keeping score at home, Epic Games raised the stakes. Rather than hype players up with a crazy loot drop, or new in-game features, the Fortnite map we all know and love disappeared. Literally, as there is currently no map to play Fortnite on. […]

BY Taylor Bauer October 14, 2019
Google Stadia Broadband Caps Cause Major Concern

There are a lot of changes coming to the video game industry. For starters, the major home console makers are setting the stage for a new generation. We’re expected to see the new PS5 and Microsoft’s Xbox Scarlett (name pending) next year for the holidays. Plus, the Switch Lite is now on shelves, providing a […]

BY Taylor Bauer October 14, 2019
Fortnite Profits Drop Steeply – Is the Fad Waning?

Flash back to the 2018 holiday season. Fortnite, a free to play multiplayer titan, seemed unstoppable. Like anything in pop culture, however, nothing lasts at its peak forever. Recent news that Fortnite profits drop steeply when you look at 2019 Q2 trends points to some positives and negatives for Epic Games moving forward. Why did […]

BY Taylor Bauer October 10, 2019

Trending

Kevin Feige Promoted to Chief Creative Officer at Marvel Studios, Overseeing, Well, Everything

That a seismic shake-up was underway at Marvel was apparent. The Sony and Disney standoff over Spider-Man, rumors that Marvel Studios would take over Marvel Television, and an ambitious MCU Phase 4 line-up. However, what that shake-up was remained a mystery until now. Kevin Feige, president of Marvel Studios, was promoted to Chief Creative Officer, […]

BY Joshua M. Patton October 15, 2019
Fortnite Chapter 2 Trailer Intros New Map

Quite possibly the biggest game around right now, Fortnite is looking to keep players interested and invested with some major changes. If you didn’t catch the Fortnite chapter 2 trailer, here’s everything you need to know about the new map and things Epic Games is introducing. Fortnite Chapter 2 Trailer Shows Off New Digs There […]

BY Taylor Bauer October 15, 2019
Doctor Doom #1 Shows He Loves Latveria More than Doom

Doctor Victor Von Doom, the ruler of the fictional country Latveria, might have the biggest ego in comics. It’s a toss-up between him and Lex Luthor, really. And as one of the biggest villains in Marvel Comics, Doom has caused mayhem and death all over the universe. So, how is it possible that he not […]

BY Roman Colombo October 15, 2019
Zoe Kravitz Will Be The Batman’s Catwoman

After a series of screen tests with various actresses, it is now official. Zoe Kravitz will play Catwoman, opposite Robert Pattinson, in Matt Reeves’s The Batman. Here are the details we know so far about her role, including, perhaps, the most surprising part of her casting. What Role Will Catwoman Play in the Upcoming Movie? […]

BY Salomé Gonstad October 15, 2019