How Can Batwoman Survive the Fan-Hate? CW Show Faces Harsh Criticism

author img
BY August 12, 2019

In just a few months, the first-ever female-led “Bat” series will premiere on the CW. It closes out Batman’s 80th anniversary year. One would think fans would be pleased to be getting more Bat-action. Even more, it’s a fresh story we’ve not seen before. Yet, instead, we are left wondering how Batwoman can survive the fan-hate directed at it. Most of it gets directed at all of the trailers released thus far. Pop culture editor Salomé Gonstad covered this initial backlash last month. As more and more trailers hit YouTube, the hate continues. Many of these folks believe Batwoman can’t survive the fan-hate, thanks to the power of the “like” to “dislike” ratio on YouTube.

In fairness, it is remarkable. The first trailer has 421,000 dislikes to 84,000 likes. The second trailer fares a little worse, with 24,000 dislikes to fewer than 2000 likes. Ironically the corniest of these promos, the “Tattoo” teaser, fares the best with 4,900 dislikes to 2,500 likes. Still, those who leverage social media to target artists, shows, and movies, can easily manipulate these figures. The first trailer for the Flash only has about 4,800 likes and an insignificant number of dislikes. The first Arrow trailer (posted on three different YouTube channels) doesn’t even have the viewcount of the first Batwoman trailer. Batwoman can survive the fan-hate, because at this stage of the game any press is good press. People will tune in for the show, and if the storytellers deliver on Kate Kane’s potential, viewers will keep coming back week after week.

Let’s Just Get This Out of the Way: A LOT of the Batwoman Fan-Hate Is Just Sexism In Action

An insidious trick perpetrated by those who stoke anger and fear of change for their own personal gain is to suggest that simply addressing things like sexism or racism is actually what’s sexist/racist. This couldn’t be more stupid. As mentioned above, Batman celebrated his 80th anniversary this year. Counting by actors who’ve played the character, in that time span fans have gotten 10 distinct live-action versions of the Caped Crusader. That number increases by about 150 percent if you include animation. So, to ask if sexism is why neither Batgirl (Barbara Gordon) nor Batwoman (Katherine/Kate Kane) had their own show or film in that time is more than fair. Originally appearing in 1956 as a love interest for Batman, DC reimagined the character 50 years later as Bruce Wayne’s maternal cousin, who just happened to be Jewish and a lesbian.

Batwoman can survive the fan-hate
Image via CW

The comments on the YouTube videos underscore that Batwoman being, well, a woman is precisely the problem. Ruby Rose’s portrayal is called “masculine” and “entitled,” as if Bruce Wayne isn’t one of the most entitled characters in all of comics. (He’s a billionaire who takes the law into his own hands and does, literally, whatever he wants to enemies and allies alike.) Yet, even though the first trailer features a character pointing out that Rose’s Kane is a “female Bruce Wayne,” these outraged man-babies say Rose’s portrayal is, actually, sexist. The also think their opinion is so powerful that there is no way Batwoman can survive the fan-hate it’s already receiving.

One commenter writes:

“It’s hilarious how they contradict their own ideology. ‘we want strong, smart, independent women!’ then they proceed to make a masculine female that dresses and acts like a guy and then dates women. Funny enough if a dude acted like that it’d be labeled toxic masculinity. So, I guess this is toxic femininity.”

Don’t waste time contemplating this rock-solid syllogism. YouTube user WeeItsNookies’ attitude highlights how what’s acceptable for a male hero isn’t acceptable for a female one. Kate Kane isn’t “feminine” enough, and her brooding anger and penchant for the ladies would never be acceptable if a man did it. Of course, Batman has never had the same love interest played by the same actor in successive movies, ever. Ruby Rose will glower all over the Arrowverse after Stephen Amell hangs up his bow. But these “fans” want her to smile more and be humble. This show isn’t Batwoman getting her due after 64 years, but rather Hollywood shoving their “social justice agenda” down viewers’ throats. Again, completely disregard that since Cap first punched Hitler in 1940, comic books often carry moral messages about bigotry and injustice. There’s no place for that “nonsense” on TV!

Misogynist Online Culture In Action

The comments are riddled with the word “Wahmen” which is an “ingenious” play on the term “woman” and the phonemicization of crying. Popularized by YouTuber PewDiePie encouraging his fans to mock women, it has become the clarion call of “Men’s Rights Activists” who enjoy the thoughtful insight of outrage merchants like Ben Shapiro or Alex Jones. Why these nincompoops are able to target Batwoman so effectively just shows the power of their reach online. Likely shared via sites that trawl the dregs of internet humanity like 4chan or the more misogynist subreddits, these Social Injustice Warriors flocked to YouTube to win the Great War of Disliking Videos Promoting Shows for Teenagers 2019. That the female empowerment message in the marketing is heavy-handed makes fills them with so much anger, they spend all day writing about a show they claim to hate.

The Batwoman Marketing Isn’t Helping the Fan-Hate Problem

Some of the criticism this show earns is not all sexist and stupid, some of it is just stupid. People are angry that it’s a Batwoman instead of Batman. Yet, Warner Bros. is very stingy with the Bat-rights, especially since CW is jointly owned by WB and CBS. So, there can’t be a Batman show. Some also think this show earning a full season somehow relates to Swamp Thing’s cancellation, despite the two productions being as separate as the MCU and the X-Men used to be. Still, these fans will likely come around or, at least, watch the show. The Arrow subreddit finds itself constantly filled with posts hating on the terrible quality of that show from people who still watch every week and know all of the developments of the series’ “terrible” seasons. They kvetch about not getting a proper Batman series but will tune in just the same.

In fairness to some of the critics, the female empowerment message (at least, in the first trailer) is heavy-handed. Even the socially aware Daily Dot said as much in their coverage about the backlash. Network marketing for the CW often shoots for the lowest common denominator, not trusting their typically young audience to catch the subtext. Likely, the show will not be as focused on this aspect of the story as many commenters think. Supergirl often features female empowerment storylines, but they do so in the context of simply great comic book stories. Batwoman will probably fall somewhere between that series and Arrow, because it’s tonally darker. And even if it does hammer its feminist perspective home in every episode of the first season, let the show have that because it’s first female-led Bat-show ever. (No disrespect to the original Birds of Prey series.)

Toxic Fandom, Gatekeeping, and Forgetting How Fiction Works

Batwoman and Ruby Rose herself are not just getting hate from the so-called “right.” Some folks on the so-called “left,” also decided to hate this show as soon as CW announced it. Their complaints, impossibly, are more ludicrous than the others. They decided that since Ruby Rose is a Jewish lesbian who identifies as genderfluid, she wasn’t “gay enough” to portray Kate Kane. Many of these critics misidentified Rose as bisexual to justify that arugment, which is also so nonsensical it would be funny were it not so hurtful. The backlash from these LGBT+ activists, a group Rose likely assumed would be supportive, drove her off of Twitter entirely. I worry for them when they also learn that Rose is not, actually, part bat.

There is nothing wrong with looking at these stories through a political lens. Arguably, you are supposed to. Yet, we’ve only seen Rose portray the character for two-and-a-half acts of an episode of Arrow. To suggest the character is bad or that the show is just a deluge of socially aware commentary is unfair. At least watch an episode or three before you decide you hate a series. What’s tragic about this is that Rose admitted she grew emotional when she learned she got the part. She thought about the kids (and adults) who would be happy to see a hero representing these demographics in something as iconic as a black batsuit. Instead of being able to enjoy this momentous occasion for both her career and the culture, she now has to wonder if Batwoman will survive the fan-hate it’s getting before it even premieres.

Y’all Are Dumb Because Batwoman Is Going to Be Dope

Batwoman can survive the fan-hate
Image via CW

Hopefully, the noise from this fabricated and inauthentic backlash gets dulled by the sound of ass-kicking and pneumatic grappling hooks. Due again to the rights issue, Amell’s Arrow essentially adopted the role of Batman in this TV Justice League. Now that he’s moving on, a real Bat-person occupies that role, but one whose story can still surprise us. Fans worry about The Batman starring Robert Pattinson. They wonder how this story will different from Tim Burton’s Batman or Batman Begins. We’ve never seen Batwoman before, so even though she will be flapping capes and busting heads, this Batman fan is as excited as he was for (children’s cartoon) Batman Beyond in 1999. Interestingly, this show also got a lot of fan-hate on the early internet because it wasn’t what fans were familiar with. Today? It’s one of the most beloved animated Batman series of all time.

We really only get to see Batwoman in action during the third and fourth acts of her episode of Arrow. But those moments were incredible. During a Scarecrow fear-gas induced fight between the Arrow and Grant Gustin’s Flash, Ruby Rose (read: her stunt double) took both of these titans down with one bad-ass flip move. Earlier when she takes out some inmates fleeing from Arkham Asylum, it’s the perfect balance of off-screen Dark Knight magic and on-screen hero posing. Also, I cheer every time she throws a batarang and it comes to back to her (LIKE BOOMERANGS ARE SUPPOSED TO!). All the CW shows are gifts to comics nerds, and this one will be no different. I know that Ruby Rose and this show can survive the fan-hate. The reason? Because she’s the goddamn Batwoman.

Batwoman premieres on October 6 at 8:00 p.m. Eastern time, followed by the fifth season premiere of Supergirl.

DCPop CultureTV Shows

Joshua M. Patton is a father, veteran, and writer living in Pittsburgh, PA. The first books he read on his own were comics, and he's loved the medium ever since. He is the greatest star-pilot in the galaxy, a cunning warrior, and a good friend. His book "What I Learned: Stories, Essays, and More" is available in print from Amazon and from all electronic booksellers.

Leave a comment


Pop CultureTV Shows
Battlestar Galactica Reboot: All Of This Has Happened Before, All Of This Will Happen Again

All of this has happened before. All of this will happen again. News broke this week about a Battlestar Galactica reboot on the way. Sam Esmail – creator of Mr. Robot – will take the reins as showrunner. The series will premiere on NBC’s new streaming service – Peacock – that will be available in […]

BY Emily O'Donnell September 17, 2019
TV Shows
The Snowpiercer TV Series Trailer Is Impressive, But Also Highly Curious

Boong Joon Ho’s epic cut hit Snowpierer is coming to TV, and the new trailer looks impressive, but also raises a lot of questions.

BY Shah Shahid July 27, 2019
Pop CultureTV Shows
Werner Herzog Is Basically Responsible for Baby Yoda Fever

In the series premiere of The Mandalorian on Disney+, one character stands above all. Baby Yoda broke the internet and warmed our hearts. However, things could have been very different if not for one figure in the series, and it’s not co-executive producers Jon Favreau and Dave Filoni. No, if you want to thank one […]

BY Joshua M. Patton November 28, 2019
Star Wars Battlefront 2 Celebration Edition is Jam Packed with Content

There’s nothing like a good redemption story. We see it all the time in comic books. A villain suddenly sees the error of their ways, turns good, and we love them for it. We don’t see it as much with video games, and no, I don’t mean characters. If a game is cast aside as […]

BY Taylor Bauer December 4, 2019
Super Mario Maker 2 Update – What’s New?

When it comes to popular Nintendo Switch games, Super Mario Maker 2 has been huge. The game is still seeing a ton of players daily, months after its release. The developers at Nintendo working on the game are ready to send more content to the game as well. In an update coming on December 5th, […]

BY Taylor Bauer December 2, 2019
Ring Fit Adventure Shortage in Japan Sparks Apology from Nintendo

It seemed a little like a joke at first, but Ring Fit Adventure is a hit. The Nintendo published fitness game for the Switch is huge all over the world. Of course, Japan took to the game quite fondly. Even here in the United States, people are really into this game. Essentially, you track movements and […]

BY Taylor Bauer December 1, 2019
RuneScape Glitch Almost Destroyed the In-Game Economy

RuneScape is a historic MMORPG with a fervent player base to this very day. For nearly 18 years, the game has brought 200 million accounts into its fantasy world. For a lot of people, a few hours on RuneScape is a part of the normal daily routine. There is a new version of the game, […]

BY Taylor Bauer November 27, 2019


Henry Cavill Disinterested in the Snyder Cut, Wants to Think About the Future of Superman

The internet is all a-flutter, because Zach Snyder confirmed that he has some cut of Justice League ready to go. Yet, the key figure in the director’s takeover of DC doesn’t seem all that interested in the movie. Henry Cavill neither saw nor cares much about the Snyder Cut, instead he is interested in the […]

BY Joshua M. Patton December 7, 2019
Wheel of Time Casting News: The Gleeman and an Ogier Join The Party

Casting news for The Wheel of Time show on Amazon Prime has been steadily rolling out. The first season is currently filming in Prague, but fans have been wondering who was going to play certain major roles. This week’s #WOTWednesday brought us the actors who will play the the gleeman Thom and the loveable Ogier named […]

BY Emily O'Donnell December 6, 2019
Zack Snyder Confirms Snyder Cut Exists In New Photo

After 2 years of back and forth, theories, assumptions and presumptions, Zack Snyder confirms Snyder Cut is very real and it exists.

BY Shah Shahid December 6, 2019
The Foundation Show on Apple TV+ Casts New Faces

An adaptation of Isaac Asimov’s Foundation series is coming to Apple TV+ and is rapidly adding cast members.  Jared Harris (Chernobyl) will play Hari Seldon, “a mathematical genius who predicts the demise of the empire.” This week brought more casting news, some of which may be surprising to book readers. Several major characters will gender-swap, […]

BY Emily O'Donnell December 6, 2019