Could Matt Smith Have Played Young Palpatine? - Comic Years
Comic Years Logo

Could Matt Smith Have Played Young Palpatine in Rise Of Skywalker?

author img
BY November 8, 2021

Somehow, Palpatine returned, and he wasted all that time building a fleet of deus ex machina when he could have been using force science to shove his brain into a new body. And that new body could have been Matt Smith. Rise of Skywalker had a lot of work to do to finish the Skywalker story, and apparently that meant there wasn’t room for a character who was to be played by Matt Smith. We must take time to mourn this loss. 

Who Would Matt Smith Have Been in Rise of Skywalker?

In the interview with Josh Horowitz where this all came out, Smith doesn’t directly state who he would have played. He does say that it was the kind of role that would have been a “transformative Star Wars detail.” When asked if the role was going to be Palpatine’s son, Smith said he “could not possibly say” which sounds like a coy way of saying “I have an NDA with the mouse and want to keep my kneecaps.”

So naturally people are wondering if Matt Smith was supposed to play some version of Sheev Palpatine. Before the part “became obsolete” maybe Palpatine’s dark secret science wasn’t cloning, it was a rejuvenating lotion that would have returned him to his young, vigorous body before the weight of the senate crushed him down. Or, instead of cloning Snokes, maybe this story had Palpatine making little Palpatines to transfer his brain into. Matt Smith would have been the right age for a version of Palpatine younger than what we saw in the prequels. Maybe when this version sucks the power from Rey and Ben, instead of repairing his body, it would just give him abs. That would explain why Smith described the role as “groovy.” How many Saturn Awards would Rise of Skywalker win with ripped Palpatine? (Answer: Not enough.)

Why Wasn’t Matt Smith in Star Wars

It just didn’t happen. Smith was in meetings discussing the part, but there was never a costume and clearly the story evolved without him. This leaves us with two things, one painful and one positive. 

Matt Smith Rise of Skywalker Image via Marvel Entertainment

The pain is that we’ll never see Palpatine talking to Rey in a hall full of test tube Snokes. We’ll never see a massive tube of red goo holding Matt Smith’s suspended body connected to a bunch of wires and electrodes. We can’t see Palpatine reveal to Rey his master plan, to inhabit the young, buff body behind him. Rey would tell him it won’t happen, that she’ll stop him. Then Palpatine would say “I’m afraid this body is quite operational.” And then he’d force throw his brain into a tube and become Matt Smith. We didn’t get that scene, and that loss deserves dedicating mourning time. 

The good news is that Matt Smith can still be in Star Wars! He could return as a young Palpatine in a later film, or he could pop up in any other role. If we got Bill Burr in Mandalorian, anything is possible.

Who do you think Matt Smith would have played in Rise of Skywalker? Send us your best theories in the comments below or talk to us on social media.

Featured image via Lucasfilm

Pop Culture

Jessica Kanzler lives with her wife and cats and enjoys obsessively reading fantasy and talking about writing with anyone who won't run away. Jessica has an MA in Rhetoric, Writing, and Digital Media studies, and one of her students once said she “wasn’t cool, but was clearly trying.”

Matt SmithPalpatineStar Wars

Leave a comment

Related

Pop CultureTV Shows
Euphoria’s One Direction Scene Reveals Fandom Truth

Euphoria, the new HBO series, is no stranger to controversy. Even before it premiered on June 16th, it was already creating buzz, similar to actress Zendaya’s other work (e.g. this Malcolm & Marie review). However, […]

BY Salomé Gonstad July 7, 2019
COMICSMarvelPop Culture
The Punisher Has a Messages for Cops Who Idolize Him: Don’t!

The most recent issue of The Punisher sends a clear message to police officers who look to the serial-murdering vigilante as a role model.

BY Joshua M. Patton July 5, 2019
COMICSMarvelPop Culture
Mysterio: Spider-Man and the Sadistic Illusionist

First Appearance of Mysterio: Amazing Spider-Man #13Created by Stan Lee and Steve Ditko Now that many of us have seen Spider-Man: Far From Home, let’s get to know the great illusionist a little better. Mysterio […]

BY Roman Colombo July 7, 2019
error: Copyright Protection