The Rental Movie Review: Dave Franco Saves Horror? - Comic Years
Comic Years Logo

The Rental Movie Review: Dave Franco Saves Horror?

author img
BY July 29, 2020

When I saw The Hunt back in March, if I’d known that it would be the last movie I’d see in a theater for months, then would I have been more generous? Pfft, absolutely not. Like Stetson Kennedy, I’m the loudest yeller, and I usually reserve that loudest yelling for horror. It is my favorite genre, after all, so I have higher standards for it than other categories, even during a pandemic. So with that attitude in mind, here’s my review of the movie The Rental.

What Is The Movie The Rental About, Exactly?

the rental movie review image via IFC Films

Dave Franco apparently hates house-sharing. Because along with Joe Swanberg (Easy), he wrote this movie, based on a story by Franco, Swanberg, and Mike Demski.

And it’s a fairly simple story. Married couple Charlie (Dan Stevens) and Michelle (Alison Brie), along with Charlie’s brother Josh (Jeremy Allen White) and his girlfriend Mina (Sheila Vand) rent a house for a celebratory weekend. I believe it’s something folks used to call a vacation? Am I saying that right? Anyway, it was where you’d leave your home and go stay somewhere else.

The group, along with Josh’s dog Reggie (Chunk), arrive at the stunning home on the Oregon coast. There they meet the owner’s brother, the caretaker Taylor (Toby Huss). There’s already a bit of tension. First of all, they’re not even supposed to have any pets there–they smuggle in Reggie. In addition, Mina had tried to book the house first, but her request was rejected. However, Charlie requested the house right after her, and Taylor accepted his booking. Mina confronts Taylor about it when they arrive, but he brushes away her concerns.

As the weekend unfolds, the tension only grows. There’s some relationship drama here that’s both implied and overt. And that might make a vacation uncomfortable enough on its own, but then things get even worse. Taylor enters the home when they’re not there. Even though he’s just dropping off a telescope, which the group had wished earlier that they’d brought, Mina is unnerved.

And then she discovers a camera in a shower head. Due to circumstances I won’t reveal (because of spoilers), she can’t share this revelation with the group. She really should have, though.

I’m Sorry, Did You Say “Dave Franco”?

Yes, this is his directorial debut.

The Rental Movie Review

the rental movie review image via IFC Films

Like I said, this is a simple story, and it’s not an unheard-of trope in horror. To wit, folks leave the house and things go bad. Franco and Swanberg don’t appear to be saying anything complex, beyond “AirBNB is creepy” or “so is the increasing surveillance in our lives,” but that’s okay. Horror doesn’t always have to be about something big to be affecting or scary or just good.

And this movie is better than good. While it wasn’t the scariest movie I’ve ever seen, Franco’s direction succeeds in ratcheting up the anxiety you feel. Along with characters like Mina, we know something is wrong here and we’re just waiting for the dam to burst.

But for me, where the story really succeeds is in the surprise. We may know that there’s something amiss, and we expect that things are going to turn sour, but when it comes to the motive or the meaning, we’re just as in the dark as the characters. And when that dam does come crumbling down, when their paranoia explodes and then it goes sideways from there, it’s killer.

Franco knows the value of keeping some things a mystery, so while the ending may leave some viewers feeling unsatisfied, it impressed me. There’s not always rhyme or reason behind scary events, and this movie understands that that’s often the scariest story of all.

So whadya know–Dave Franco may have made the best horror movie of the year.

Oh and before y’all ask, no, the dog does not die.

The Rental is available for, uh, rental right now on video on demand sites like Google Play, Vudu, and Amazon Prime Video. You can see the trailer below.

Have you watched The Rental yet? Share your thoughts with us about it in the comments or on social media.

featured image via IFC Films


Salomé Gonstad is a freelance writer who grew up in the swampy wilds of south Alabama. When she's not yelling about pop culture on the internet, she's working on a supernatural thriller about her hometown. Also, we're pretty sure she's a werewolf. Email her at

Dave FrancohorrorMoviesThe Rental

Leave a comment


1995 Movie Colony Mutation: Love Stinks

If you look at the promo art for the 1995 movie Colony Mutation, then you might be fooled. It kind of looks like the Gigeresque nightmares from the Alien movies, right? But that’s where you’d […]

BY Salomé Gonstad October 30, 2020
Little Monsters Movie Bringing Universal Creatures Back to Life

The Universal movie monsters are cultural artifacts that rarely get their dues. We know them and many still enjoy the old black-and-white films from yesteryear. Still, they rarely show up in productive or meaningful ways. […]

BY Taylor Bauer July 13, 2020
MoviesPop Culture
Rick Moranis May Come Out of Retirement for New Honey, I Shrunk the Kids Movie (UPDATED)

In 1997, one of the most famous faces in comedy films went away. Rick Moranis, known for his roles in Ghostbusters, Spaceballs, and Honey, I Shrunk the Kids, took a hiatus from acting. His reason […]

BY Joshua M. Patton February 4, 2020

Rail Ad Editorial Content

Rail Ad