‘Joker’ Wins At Venice Film Festival; Will It Be The One To Legitimize Comic Book Movies At Awards? 

author img
BY September 7, 2019

An origin story about a comic book villain has won the top prize at the Venice Film Festival. Todd Phillips’ Joker, starring Joaquin Phoenix as the titular character, has won the Golden Lion at the acclaimed film festival. Could we be on the verge of legitimizing comic book properties in the eyes of the awards-circuit?

Joker is a DC Comics villain mostly associated with Batman. The character has seen many different iterations, from TV to animation to feature film. Phoenix is the latest to portray the role in an unprecedented standalone origin movie. Even though Warner Bros is producing the movie, the film is separate from the studios’ DC Extended Universe movies, with no connections to any other story.

The marketing campaign for Joker has been impressively nuanced. The movie that threw everyone for a loop seemed to be taking a different approach with how it regarded the Batman villain. And now, the Todd Phillips directed Joker movie, has stepped foot into an arena occupied by few other films. Winning an accolade usually reserved for movies that go on to become Best Picture nominations at the Oscars.

But how did we get here?

Joker Movie’s Announcement Met With Confusion and Derision

I still remember when a stand-alone Joker movie was first announced. The sting of Jared Leto’s Joker performance in Suicide Squad from a year ago was still fresh. So the raised eye brows, massive eye rolls, and audible scoffs at another misguided attempt by Warner Bros. and DC Comics were understandable. The disappointment of Justice League a few weeks later would further cement this feeling. This was also at a time when other stories of a spin-off of Leto’s Joker and Margot Robbie’s Harley Quinn circled the entertainment media circles.

Jared Leto as Joker in a still from 'Sucide Squad'. Maybe be a little serious? (Image via Warner Bros.)

The news of a Joker movie, directed by Todd Phillips, until then widen known simply for the Hangover movies, seemed baffling. It was yet another sign of the WB not knowing how to deal with their DC Comics properties in the cinematic universe. But signs of hope were coming.

The First Glimmer At The End Of The Tunnel

When news broke that Todd Phillips was directing Joker, it also included the name of one of Hollywood most legendary filmmakers, Martin Scorsese, as producer. While that ultimately was not the case, the homages and influences by Scorsese on Phillips have been undeniable.

Then came the casting of the lead, Joaquin Phoenix himself. The Oscar-nominated actor has established himself as an immensely talented actor whose films are always of note. So with his leading the Joker cast, impressions of the movie swiftly did a 180 turn.

Poster for 'Joker'. Image via Warner Bros.

As new images, set photos, posters, and trailers of the film released, Phillip’s Scorsese connection made sense. Phoenix’s costumes seemed similar to those of Robert DeNiro’s in Scorsese’s own The King Of Comedy. Even the story of Joker seemed oddly similar; about a comedian descending into madness. And finally, when Robert DeNiro was cast in the movie itself, things began to take shape.

Joaquin Phoenix Privately Pitched This Movie To His Agent

Fans love when a film comes from passion and personal interest, instead of through a desire to make money or other business reasons. So when Phoenix revealed how he had an idea for this Joker movie years ago, fans were decidedly on board for Joker.

“Three or four years ago, I called my agent and said ‘Why don’t they want to take one of these characters and just make a lower budget film about it, a movie but a character study, and why not take one of the villains?’ And I thought, ‘You can’t do the Joker, because, you know, it’s just you can’t do that character, it’s just been done.’”

Will Joker Finally Give Comic Book Properties Awards Recognition?

Joker winning the Golden Lion at the Venice Film Festival is a big deal. For years now, comic book movie fans have latched onto any signs of acknowledgement of their beloved movies by the awards’ circuit; the people regarded as insiders of the industry. This was not out of a misguided sense of validation. But from a need to be accepted as part of an industry that is made up of people from all over the world that love stories. An acknowledgement that art comes in many forms.

An image of Joaquin Phoenix from 'Joker'. Image via Warner Bros.

We took any nomination, any acclaim, and any win as one step closer to that goal. When The Dark Knight received a posthumous Best Supporting Oscar win for Heath Ledger.  Logan’s nomination for the Best Adapted Screenplay Oscar. And most recently, Black Panther’s nomination for the Best Picture Oscar, that won for Best Costume, Music, and Production instead. But Joker could bridge that gap from commercially successful to the type of critical darlings that award voters love.

Joker’s Win Is Indicative Of A Larger Awards Circuit Contention

Most big budget Hollywood productions rarely win at Venice, much less a comic book property. The previous winners of the same award included Guillermo Del Toro’s The Shape Of Water and Alfonso Cuaron’s Roma. Both films were the top contenders at the Oscars in their respective years. With both also winning multiple Oscars in various categories.

Joker’s win is an achievement to the film itself. As well as the directing talent of Todd Phillips and the intense performance of Joaquin Phoenix. The film releases everywhere in November 2019.

Until then, Joker will continue on its award circuit tour with a stop at the Toronto International Film Festival. Time will tell if the win at Venice is truly indicative of great things for the film, or just a one-off.

Do you think Joker will be the one to legitimize comic book movies for the industry award voters? Let us know your thoughts below.


Shah Shahid is an entertainment writer, movie critic (so he thinks), host of the Split Screen Podcast (on Apple Podcasts & everywhere else) and filmy father on a mission to educate his girls on decades of film history. Armed with uncontrollable sarcasm and cautious optimism, Shah loves discussing film, television and comic book content until his wife’s eyes glaze over. So save her by engaging him on his own blog at BlankPageBeatdown.com or on Twitter @theshahshahid.

Leave a comment


The Lion King Remake Takes “Remake” To Its Most Literal Meaning

I’m not against the live-action remakes of classic Disney films. Aladdin, back in May, actually surprised me by how good it was. Dumbo was adorable. Beauty and the Beast had enough of a spin on the story, showing us new sides to characters we already loved. Jungle Book was exceptionally new. The upcoming Mulan looks […]

BY Roman Colombo July 30, 2019
Netflix Drops Trailer for The King

In Neflix’s attempt to come back to the Oscars next year, it has dropped its next viable choice, The King. Alongside The Irishman and Marriage Story, the streaming service has The King to complete a trio of Academy Awards contenders. Directed by David Michôd and co-written with Joel Edgerton, The King features A-list stars and is based on […]

BY Meghan Hale August 28, 2019
New Details on Sony and Marvel Spider-Man Contract: Spidey Needs to Make a Billion

New details about the Sony and Marvel Spider-Man contract reveal that the latest film has to hit a billion dollars to keep Spidey in the MCU.

BY Joshua M. Patton July 12, 2019
History of the Wii U – A Console Gone Wrong

A lot of our history posts on gaming have been about a series like Gears of War or Halo. As a huge Nintendo fan, however, I think we need to take a look at a recent console. It’s tough to say exactly what sort of impact the Wii U had on gaming at the time […]

BY Taylor Bauer September 14, 2019
Ring Fit Adventure is the Latest Fitness Game for Nintendo Switch

When Wii Fit came out, people wondered who would actually use it. As it turned out, a lot of people enjoyed playing games while they did mild exercise. The game’s sequel even made its way to the Wii U. The appeal of a game like Wii Fit is the ability to engage with the workout. […]

BY Taylor Bauer September 13, 2019
Apple’s Gaming Service Gets Price and Launch Date

There are a lot of ideas from Apple that sound crazy at first. Nobody imagined you could carry 30,000 songs in your pocket. Everyone wondered if an expensive tablet could replace their desktop computer. We’ve been in this position before. Apple’s gaming service, Arcade, is one of those ideas that seems like a potential miss. […]

BY Taylor Bauer September 11, 2019
New Pokémon Anime ‘Pocket Monsters’ Has Some Fans Worried

With the Pokemon universe growing after a hit live-action movie & a popular mobile game, some fans are worried about a new Anime series.

BY Shah Shahid September 10, 2019


Alternate Iron Man Post-Credits Scene Shows Nick Fury Talking About an Even Bigger MCU

At the end of the first Iron Man film, Robert Downey Jr.’s Tony Stark met Samuel L. Jackson’s Nick Fury, and superhero movies changed forever. The big advantage Marvel Studios had over other franchises was its deep roster of characters and stories. A new, never-before-seen alternate Iron Man post-credits scene presents fans with a much […]

BY Joshua M. Patton September 14, 2019
Epic Comic Book Events: How Did the Big Crossovers Start (And Why do We Keep Buying Them?!)

Every year, Marvel and DC Comics have some kind of major Comic Book Events that, at least temporarily, shakes up the status quo if their heroes. It used to be “this year’s event”—now we see two or three a year. At Marvel, in 2019, the X-Men had an apparently universe-changing event with Age of X-Man […]

BY Roman Colombo September 14, 2019
History of the Wii U – A Console Gone Wrong

A lot of our history posts on gaming have been about a series like Gears of War or Halo. As a huge Nintendo fan, however, I think we need to take a look at a recent console. It’s tough to say exactly what sort of impact the Wii U had on gaming at the time […]

BY Taylor Bauer September 14, 2019
TIFF Honey Boy Review – An Authentic Script & Phenomenal Performances

Amongst all of the sequels, franchises, and terror-filled films, Honey Boy stands out like a breath of fresh air at TIFF. In fact, a lot of Shia LaBeouf’s post-Transformers films seem to do so. Borg vs McEnroe, American Honey, and more recently, The Peanut Butter Falcon aren’t the kinds of films you’d ever have expected from the Hollywood Bad Boy […]

BY Meghan Hale September 14, 2019