Harriet: Cynthia Erivo Delivers on the American Hero Despite Problematic Historical Inaccuracies

author img
BY November 7, 2019

When we learn about Harriet Tubman in elementary school, it’s a bit tame. We know she helped enslaved people find their way to freedom through the “underground railroad”—and how many of us pictured an actual steam-powered train underground? But she is so much more than that. She was a true life action hero, not just being one of the few women in American history to lead troops into battle, during the Civil War, but she was a Union spy too. A movie based on her life should be an easy sell, especially in a post-Black Panther era. A three-hour epic of war, freedom, and glory. Now, we finally get an amazing actress, Cynthia Erivo, portraying Harriet. Does the film measure up to the legend?

Cynthia Erivo Carries the Film From Start to Finish

Harriet Tubman, Cynthia Erivo (Image Via: Focus Features)

As the credits roll, the first feeling I got was “wow—that was incredible.” But really, I should have thought. “wow, Cynthia Erivo was incredible as Harriet.” Erivo is a fast-rising actress. She stole the show in Bad Times at the El Royale, matching the talent and power of her costar Jeff Bridges. Bridges is one of those actors that is so good that it’s easy to forget that there are other actors around him. He’s so good, they used him twice in Tron: Legacy, and I’m still not sure who else starred in that movie. But Erivo was ever-present next to him. And in Harriet, she fills the film the way Bridges fills most of his. She’s a commanding presence. She is the movie.

The Rest of Harriet is Filled with Historical Inaccuracies

In Schooled, the Goldbergs spinoff, the teachers all go to see Star Wars Episode I: The Phantom Menace, and they all love it. Until they start asking questions, and the more they ask, the more they’re unsure about the movie. Harriet suffers the same issue. Despite Cynthia Erivo’s incredible portrayal of Harriet Tubman, there are aspects of the film that feel off. And, with just a moment of internet research, you start seeing how off it is. One of the villains is a black man who hunts down fugitive slaves for their bounties. He’s a vicious presence in the film, and the biggest threat to Harriet. He also didn’t exist. Then there’s a character who talks and acts like a Jazz-era gangster wearing Davey Crocket’s hat.

Janelle Monáe, Cynthia Erivo Janelle Monáe’s character didn’t exist either. (Image Via: Focus Features)

And sadly, the film only covers a lot of what we already know. We get a glimpse of her time in the Civil War, but the two-hour runtime is dedicated to her underground railroad years. Important, but it’s like shrinking Fellowship of the Ring to two hours and ending with “And then Frodo destroyed the ring.” There’s just so much left unexplored.

And Yet, Harriet Still Has its Charm

Harriet Tubman, Focus Features, Historical Movies (Image Via: Focus Features)

I’m mentioning a lot of other movies, but they help to show the same issues. This time, it’s the Guy Pierce-starring Count of Monte Cristo. That movie was a 120-minute version of a 1300ish page novel, and one of my favorite novels at that. The movie changes so much that the book is barely recognizable…but it’s still a pretty fun movie. You know it’s inaccurate. You know a lot of liberties were taken. But the end result is still a good movie. Harriet, despite all its flaws, is still a good movie. Just don’t go into it thinking it’s a definitive biography. And seeing Cynthia Erivo play Harriet is worth it alone.

Grade: Where’s my 20-dollar Bill with Harriet Tubman?

So, will the Oscars be Renée Zellwegger’s Judy vs. Cynthia Erivo’s Harriet? Both women are incredible, but my money’s on Judy. She’s small, but she’s scrappy.

(Featured Image Via: Focus Features)

Movies

Roman Colombo finished his MFA in 2010 and now teaches writing and graphic novel literature at various Philadelphia colleges. His first novel, Trading Saints for Sinners, was published in 2014. He's currently working on his next novel and hoping to find an agent soon.

Leave a comment

Related

DCMoviesPop Culture
The Batman Movie Leaks Suggest Matt Reeves Plans a Story We’ve Not Seen On-Screen Before

The next Batman film will be the 11th live-action feature to showcase the iconic character. As per usual, details about this movie are closely guarded. Yet, recent Batman movie leaks may give fans some insight into what sort of film we’re going to get from Matt Reeves in 2021. Let me just state upfront, only […]

BY Joshua M. Patton September 10, 2019
MarvelMovies
BREAKING: Standoff Between Sony and Disney Threatens Spider-Man’s Future in the MCU

Standoff Between Sony and Disney VS Spider-Man’s Future in the MCU For months, fans and insiders alike awaited the news that Sony and Marvel Studios extended their unprecedented deal to share the Spider-Man character. However, news broke on Tuesday that a standoff between Sony and Disney may effectively end Spider-Man’s participation in the Marvel Cinematic […]

BY Joshua M. Patton August 20, 2019
Movies
Zombieland: Double Tap Review: A Movie We Didn’t Need, But Are Happy To Have

When a great movie is released, it doesn’t take long for people to start whispering desires about a sequel. So, when Zombieland released in 2009, people assumed that a sequel may follow closely afterward. Well, after years of no news, fans gave up hope. To the surprise of plenty, the sequel, Zombieland: Double Tap was announced back in July […]

BY Meghan Hale October 19, 2019
Google Stadia Launch is Missing Key, Promised Features

So here’s the thing; it’s easy to get excited about an idea. Something like 4K game streaming, top titles and developers on board, and a new way to play sounds great. The Google Stadia launch is fast approaching, and a recent Reddit AMA about the console raises major concerns about the state in which this […]

BY Taylor Bauer November 14, 2019
Best Exclusive Sony Series of All Time

It goes without saying that Sony wins this round of the Console Wars. While some people hate to think of gaming, as a war, it sort of is. Most gamers are going to buy one console, meaning each major company does what it can to influence consumers to buy their brand. With insane exclusives and […]

BY Taylor Bauer November 13, 2019
Pokemon Hashtag Goes Viral – #ThankYouGameFreak

It’s been a tumultuous built up to Pokemon Sword and Shield. Because of the game’s limited Pokemon roster, hundreds of characters won’t be playable in the new games. Fans are fairly upset, and in a way, they have a right to be. It’s the first time that you won’t be able to transfer Pokemon from […]

BY Taylor Bauer November 11, 2019
EA Renews Skate Trademark, But No New Game Likely

People got really deflated and then somewhat excited about a trademark this morning. One of EA’s most dedicated fan-bases are obsessed with the Skate games. There hasn’t been a new game for 10 years, but it’s not something we can rule out. When you read that EA renews Skate trademark, it’s easy to get excited, […]

BY Taylor Bauer November 8, 2019

Trending

Google Stadia Launch is Missing Key, Promised Features

So here’s the thing; it’s easy to get excited about an idea. Something like 4K game streaming, top titles and developers on board, and a new way to play sounds great. The Google Stadia launch is fast approaching, and a recent Reddit AMA about the console raises major concerns about the state in which this […]

BY Taylor Bauer November 14, 2019
The Top 10 Fantasy Series Published In The Past Decade

The end of the decade is rapidly approaching. The 2010’s were good for sci-fi & fantasy fans as shows like Game of Thrones, and huge movie franchises like the Marvel Cinematic Universe brought genre into the mainstream. The decade was great for books as well, with several huge epics finally reaching their conclusions (Wheel of Time). […]

BY Emily O'Donnell November 14, 2019
Netflix Orders A Second Season for The Witcher Ahead Of Premiere

One month until the premiere of The Witcher series on Netflix, and a second season has already been ordered. Showrunner Lauren Hissrich announced the news today via Twitter.  I’m so thrilled to announce: Geralt, Yennefer, and Ciri will be back for more adventures… in Season Two. I could not be more proud of what the […]

BY Emily O'Donnell November 14, 2019
Netflix and Nickelodeon To Collaborate With Multi-Year Deal

Hot off the trails of Disney+’s massive release, Netflix has added an exciting announcement for its subscribers. Netflix will be collaborating with Nickelodeon on a multi-year deal, working to produce original animated content. This will include films and television series, featuring old, beloved Nickelodeon characters, as well as completely new content. What This Nickelodeon Deal […]

BY Meghan Hale November 14, 2019