There’s a new debate online that I think might be worth having. I’ll be honest, I’m sort of torn, so I figured it might be worth it to go over what’s happening. News that SEGA Europe is abandoning plastic video game packaging got everyone talking. Overall, the change is very limited. The move to recyclable cardboard packaging is only going to apply to PC games. But, it got me thinking, should we be considering the plastic toll video game packaging takes? The idea is, at the very least, worth entertaining.
How Harmful is Plastic Video Game Packaging?
Image Credit: University of Sydney (AU)
The change at SEGA Europe came from the team at Sports Interactive. Sports Interactive makes the highly popular Football Manager series, one of Europe’s top selling PC titles. According to their research, each plastic video game packaging uses 55 g (1.9 oz) of plastic. The move isn’t just a PR stunt; in fact, SEGA Europe is “hoping to inspire others to follow their lead,” according to their announcement.
I think a lot of people might scoff at the idea of abandoning plastic video game packaging. For the most part, a lot of people are behind skipping plastic water bottles when possible. For reference, a plastic water bottle only uses around 11g of plastic particles. That means, roughly, 5 plastic water bottles are the equivalent to a video games case. Still, there are some things to keep in mind about the move.
The Actual Threat of Plastic
There are some pretty gross facts about plastic water bottle worth mentioning before we move on. For example, 90% of the cost of bottled water is the bottle itself. That’s a ton of money going into the construction of something truly terrible for our environment. “Plastic bottles require up to 700 years to dissolve,” and “38 million plastic bottles go to landfills each year in America alone.” As SEGA Europe recognizes, the cost to produce cardboard is going to be more expensive. The company believes it’ll be about 20 pence a piece. To them, and hopefully to all of us, that change is worth it.
Concerns for Video Game Collectors
Image Credit: eBay
As of now, the change is only for PC game cases. Still, the argument exists that changing console game cases would even be more impactful. Overall, most PC gamers buy their games digitally. Console gamers still largely buy physical copies of games, especially if they’re into video games as investments. I collect games, and while I don’t really ever look to sell, the abandonment of plastic cases does mean some significant changes.
Firstly, cardboard is a lot tougher to keep pristine. Not unlike comic collectors, concerns about bending, creasing, wrinkles, and other deforming blemishes increase with a move to paper-based boxing. Ask any Nintendo 64 collector, and they’ll tell you those cardboard boxes really make things tough to preserve as the decades pass. Secondly, cardboard boxes are going to take up a lot more space. It’s easy to store plastic game cases for their small size. While the cardboard boxes aren’t huge, they do take up a bit more space.
Lastly, and probably most selfishly, a lot of collectors aren’t going to like the look of cardboard. This of course brings us to the heart of the debate. Is any of this worth arguing against a move that benefits the planet? Try telling that to corporations who don’t want to take on additional costs.
Why a Debate About Plastic Video Game Packaging Is Fine to Have, But Ultimately Simple
Image Credit: eBay
I think two major issues exist with the debate on plastic video game packaging. Firstly, companies are hesitant to make a positive change that costs them more money. We’ve seen time and time again that corporations worry about the bottom line before the planet. While it’s great for us as consumers to use metal straws and avoid plastic silverware, the real harm to the Earth isn’t us. Overall, companies need to do more as they are contributing to the majority of harmful emissions and waste.
Secondly, video game collectors like myself have every right to have a preference. Overall, the wishes of someone planning the look of their gaming area don’t get superseded by environmental concerns. I think it’d take some getting used to for collectors if console games moved to cardboard. Still, how much can we value the discontent of video game collectors against a ton of plastic waste?
Is There a Chance that Plastic Video Game Packaging is Banned Entirely?
I don’t think plastic video game packaging is going anywhere anytime soon. In short, I don’t believe any ban will exist at all. Still, moves like the decision made by SEGA Europe should be celebrated. If we can’t make companies care about the environment, then we can certainly celebrate companies who practice sustainability on their own. It’s wonderful that many game companies agreed last year to reduce their environmental impact. Hopefully, the trend continues as the world reckons with the long lasting effects of plastic waste and carbon emissions.
Do you like hearing about the intersection of video games and current events in the world? Let us know if we should cover things like this more often! Thanks for choosing Comic Years for your news on gaming, comics, and pop culture.
Taylor loves to play video games in his spare time. He has two degrees in Political Communication and wrote his thesis on Marxism and the exploitation of college athletes. In his spare time, he loves spending time with his wife and two Toy Australian Sheppards. He’s always got headphones in, and he’s a diehard Cubs fan.